Comparisons
Compare TOMMY Zero with other Wi-Fi and RF sensing projects. See how different approaches to presence detection stack up in terms of technology, cost, and openness.
Overview
A few projects today tackle motion and presence detection using Wi-Fi or other RF signals. Each takes a different approach, with different trade-offs around hardware, accuracy, ecosystem, and openness. Below is how they differ in required components, zone types, presence detection, openness, and price. Follow the links further down for a deeper comparison against TOMMY Zero.
Required components
TOMMY Zero
TOMMY Zero serverHome Assistant app or Docker container
ESP32 boardsAt least one
ESPectre
No serverEach board processes its own data
ESP32 boardsAt least one
Hue MotionAware
Hue Bridge ProRequired for MotionAware
Philips Hue lightsAt least three
Compatibility
Direct flashingFlash a dedicated board from the browser.
ESPHomeAdd sensing to a device that already runs ESPHome.
Philips Hue lightsRuns on compatible Hue lights.
TOMMY Zero
ESPectre
Hue MotionAware
Zone types
TOMMY Zero4 zone types
ESPectre2 zone types
Hue MotionAware1 zone type
Calibration
TOMMY Zero
Not neededDetection starts as soon as the zone is set up.
ESPectre
Not neededDetects from the start.
Hue MotionAware
At setupThe area must be empty while the lights calibrate.
Algorithms
← Stays inside the roomFalse positives through walls →
TOMMY Zero3 algorithms
ContainedIgnores movement on the other side of wallsStandardBalances sensitivity and through-wall leakageRadarSenses everything the devices pick up
ESPectre2 algorithms
Lightweight and High AccuracySenses everything the devices pick up
Hue MotionAware1 algorithm
StandardBalances sensitivity and through-wall leakage
Key facts
TOMMY ZeroESPectreHue MotionAware
Released17 August 20252 November 20254 September 2025
TechnologyChannel State Information (CSI)Channel State Information (CSI)Zigbee fluctuations
Stationary presenceWith an ESP32-C5Motion onlyMotion only
Open sourceClosed sourceGPL-3.0Closed source
Price14-day free trial with everything in Pro. Pro is a one-time purchaseFreeIncluded with the Hue Bridge Pro
Individual Comparisons
For how Wi-Fi sensing compares to mmWave sensors in general, see mmWave vs Wi-Fi sensing.