TOMMY Zero vs ESPectre
Compare TOMMY Zero's Wi-Fi sensing with ESPectre, an open-source Wi-Fi CSI motion detection project. Technology, setup, and capabilities compared.
At a glance
Required components
Compatibility
Zone types
Calibration
Algorithms
Key facts
Overview
ESPectre and TOMMY Zero both detect people by analyzing Wi-Fi Channel State Information (CSI) on ESP32 devices, but they take different approaches. ESPectre is an open-source (GPL-3.0) project where a single ESP32 senses the Wi-Fi link between itself and the access point it is connected to, or between two ESPectre boards. TOMMY Zero is a closed-source system. A router zone senses with a single ESP32 and the router you choose, and zones with several ESP32 devices measure the signals between each other. That lets you define zones by where you place the devices, and it can detect people who are sitting still.
If motion detection along the path to your access point is enough and you want an open-source solution, ESPectre is a solid option. If you need stationary presence, zones placed independently of your router, or a dashboard that handles mesh networks for you, TOMMY Zero is a better fit.
How the zone types compare
ESPectre's main setup, a single ESP32 sensing the link to the access point it is connected to, is what TOMMY Zero calls a router zone. Both start with one board and your router.
TOMMY Zero also has two zone types that do not involve the router:
- A zone uses two or more ESP32 devices and senses the space between them. ESPectre's direct link between two boards is the closest match, but a zone can use more than two devices, and every device you add covers more.
- A group is several zones that share one device, so each zone needs only one more device of its own. ESPectre has no equivalent.
Technology Comparison
| Aspect | TOMMY Zero | ESPectre |
|---|---|---|
| Released | 17 August 2025 | 2 November 2025 |
| Technology | Wi-Fi sensing (Channel State Information) | Wi-Fi sensing (Channel State Information) |
| Zone types | Router zone (one ESP32 and your router), zone (two or more ESP32 devices), and group (zones sharing a device) | One ESP32 and the access point, which matches a router zone. Two boards can also form a direct link |
| Sensing paths | Router zone: device to router Zone: device to device, where the ESP32 devices measure the links between each other Group: device to device, where zones share one device | Device to access point. The ESP32 measures the link between itself and the access point it is connected to. Two ESPectre boards can also measure a direct link |
| Detection | Motion and stationary presence | Motion |
| Processing | On the TOMMY Zero server | On the ESP32 |
Comparison
Device Requirements
| Aspect | TOMMY Zero | ESPectre |
|---|---|---|
| Device count | 1 ESP32 device for a router zone, or 2 or more per zone, plus a server running TOMMY Zero. A device can be shared by several zones, so neighboring zones need fewer devices | 1 ESP32 device, or 2 for a direct link, no server |
| Device compatibility | ESP32, ESP32-C3, ESP32-C5, ESP32-C6, ESP32-S2, ESP32-S3 | ESP32, ESP32-C3, ESP32-C5, ESP32-C6, ESP32-S2, ESP32-S3 |
Sensing Capabilities
| Aspect | TOMMY Zero | ESPectre |
|---|---|---|
| Zones | A router zone covers the path to the router you choose, and on a mesh network you pick which node. Zones and groups are freely defined by placing devices | Tied to the path between the ESP32 and the access point, or between two boards. Covering a different area means moving the boards or the access point |
| Mesh networks | Handled automatically. TOMMY Zero keeps each zone on one Wi-Fi channel | Pin the access point or peer manually to keep the path fixed |
| Obstacle penetration | Can detect presence through obstacles and walls | Can detect motion through obstacles and walls |
| Motion filtering | Cannot differentiate between human movement and other moving objects (pets, curtains, fans, etc.). Human vs. non-human filtering planned for 2027 | Cannot differentiate between human movement and other moving objects (pets, curtains, fans, etc.) |
| Stationary presence sensing | Supported with compatible hardware (see Detection Mode) | Not supported |
Setup and Integration
| Aspect | TOMMY Zero | ESPectre |
|---|---|---|
| Installation | Install the server as a Home Assistant App or Docker container, then flash the devices from the dashboard over USB or through ESPHome | Add it to an ESPHome device, or flash the standalone firmware |
| Configuration | Dashboard for zones, devices, and tuning | YAML options, plus tuning entities in Home Assistant |
| Home Assistant integration | Native integration with automatic entity creation | Through ESPHome's native API, or MQTT discovery with the standalone firmware |
| ESPHome support | Supported | Supported |
Privacy and Cost
| Aspect | TOMMY Zero | ESPectre |
|---|---|---|
| Privacy | Runs locally. Needs internet access for license verification | Runs locally, no internet access needed |
| System type | Closed-source, proprietary system | Open source (GPL-3.0) |
| Price | 14-day free trial with everything in Pro. Pro is a one-time purchase | Free |
Use Cases
When to choose TOMMY Zero
- You need stationary presence sensing, for example someone sitting still on a sofa or at a desk
- You want to start with a single board and add more later to place zones where you need them
- You have a mesh network and want it handled for you
- You want a dashboard to set up and tune zones instead of YAML
When to choose ESPectre
- You want a fully open-source solution and are comfortable with GPL-3.0
- Motion detection along the path to your access point covers your use case
- You want a single device with no server and no software cost